DANS - Data Archiving and Networked Services

Search datasets

EASY offers sustainable archiving of research data and access to thousands of datasets.

Close Search help

Data Papers as a New Form of Knowledge Organization in the Field of Research Data

Cite as:

Schöpfel, Dr. J. (University of Lille, GERiiCO laboratory) (): Data Papers as a New Form of Knowledge Organization in the Field of Research Data. DANS. https://doi.org/10.17026/dans-zk3-jkyb

2019-05-29 Schöpfel, Dr. J. (University of Lille, GERiiCO laboratory) 10.17026/dans-zk3-jkyb

In order to analyse specific features of data papers, we established a representative sample of data journals, based on lists from the European FOSTER Plus project , the German wiki forschungsdaten.org hosted by the University of Konstanz and two French research organizations.
The complete list consists of 82 data journals, i.e. journals which publish data papers. They represent less than 0,5% of academic and scholarly journals. For each of these 82 data journals, we gathered information about the discipline, the global business model, the publisher, peer reviewing etc. The analysis is partly based on data from ProQuest’s Ulrichsweb database, enriched and completed by information available on the journals’ home pages.
One part of the data journals are presented as “pure” data journals stricto sensu , i.e. journals which publish exclusively or mainly data papers. We identified 28 journals of this category (34%). For each journal, we assessed through direct search on the journals’ homepages (information about the journal, author’s guidelines etc.) the use of identifiers and metadata, the mode of selection and the business model, and we assessed different parameters of the data papers themselves, such as length, structure, linking etc.
The results of this analysis are compared with other research journals (“mixed” data journals) which publish data papers along with regular research articles, in order to identify possible differences between both journal categories, on the level of data papers as well as on the level of the regular research papers. Moreover, the results are discussed against concepts of knowledge organization.